A Good Man Read online

  Praise for A Good Man

  “Ani Katz is a brilliant writer. I sat down to read A Good Man and didn’t move until I’d finished it. This is a spellbinding work of psychologically potent art. I can’t wait to read what she does next. I loved this book.”

  —Caroline Kepnes, bestselling author of You and Providence

  “A profoundly disturbing and deeply unsettling story of a man struggling to reconcile himself with the horrifying act he has committed. Katz deftly embodies her narrator, giving voice to his self-serving re-creation of the past and presenting him as he sees himself: a provider, a protector, a patriarch. Richly drawn and laced through with dread, this bold novel is an unflinching examination of what it means to be a man, and how easily a man can become a monster.”

  —Kathleen Barber, author of Are You Sleeping

  “Katz draws a life in its most delicate lines, then destroys it. And this is a story you won’t forget.”

  —Nico Walker, New York Times bestselling author of Cherry

  “Gripping, sly, and ferociously intelligent. I couldn’t put it down.”

  —Jennifer duBois, author of Cartwheel and The Spectators

  “A Good Man slinks into the dark heart of a ripped-from-the-headlines crime fueled by toxic masculinity. As in Leila Slimani’s The Perfect Nanny, the slow unpeeling—layer by layer—of the conventions of sanity left me breathless, saddened, and spooked.”

  —Miranda Beverly-Whittemore, New York Times bestselling author of Bittersweet and June

  “A Good Man will hold you in its creeping spell from the first lyrical line to the bitter, bitter end. As the narrator’s tale of selfless, industrious striving on his family’s behalf unravels, you’ll be too caught up to look away from the ugly business of a ‘good man’ bringing himself and the others around him down. Ani Katz’s debut is a gorgeously written, profound examination of contemporary masculinity and its potentially lethal side effects.”

  —Laura Sims, author of Looker

  PENGUIN BOOKS

  A GOOD MAN

  Ani Katz is a writer, photographer, and teacher. She was born and raised on the South Shore of Long Island, New York, and holds an MFA in photography from Columbia College Chicago and a BA from Yale. She lives in Brooklyn.

  PENGUIN BOOKS

  An imprint of Penguin Random House LLC

  penguinrandomhouse.com

  Copyright © 2020 by Ani Katz

  Penguin supports copyright. Copyright fuels creativity, encourages diverse voices, promotes free speech, and creates a vibrant culture. Thank you for buying an authorized edition of this book and for complying with copyright laws by not reproducing, scanning, or distributing any part of it in any form without permission. You are supporting writers and allowing Penguin to continue to publish books for every reader.

  LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA

  Names: Katz, Ani, author.

  Title: A good man : a novel / Ani Katz.

  Description: [New York] : Penguin Books, [2020] | Identifiers: LCCN 2019029704 (print) | LCCN 2019029705 (ebook) | ISBN 9780143134985 (paperback) | ISBN 9780525506645 (ebook)

  Subjects: GSAFD: Suspense fiction.

  Classification: LCC PS3611.A78868 G66 2020 (print) | LCC PS3611.A78868 (ebook) | DDC 813/.6—dc23

  LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019029704

  LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019029705

  This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents either are the product of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, businesses, companies, events, or locales is entirely coincidental.

  Cover design: Julianna Lee

  Cover photograph: plainpicture / Régis Domergue

  Version_1

  For my grandparents:

  Murray, a mensch

  and Lillian, a lover of opera

  CONTENTS

  Praise for A Good Man

  About the Author

  Title Page

  Copyright

  Dedication

  Prologue

  Chapter I

  Chapter II

  Chapter III

  Chapter IV

  Acknowledgments

  The billy club arrived with the first shipment of Christmas presents that year, one package among several stacked on the front porch. The snow had started in the late afternoon, and by the time I got home from work the lawn was dusted with powder. The girls were still out—ballet maybe, or a violin lesson. In the hush of the early dark, I knelt and gathered the gifts in my arms, then carried them into our house.

  The club had made the long journey coastward from the home of an amateur craftsman in War Eagle, Arkansas, who’d advertised the club on eBay as an absolutely terrific tire and fish thumper. Carved from Ozark red cedar, the club was about the size of a T-ball bat, and it had a nice old-fashioned look to it, like something you’d hang in your study instead of your garage. Wrapped around the rich wood barrel, held in place by a rubber band, there was a sheet of paper—a letter from the seller, which I lost almost immediately. The missive must have been shuffled in with the old school flyers and grocery lists and holiday cards, tossed out with the rest of the paper ephemera that was always blanketing the kitchen counter.

  But I remember most of what the letter said. It was a testimony of faith, one man’s deliverance from death through the power of prayer. Stricken by pancreatic cancer, the seller had given up on life, but one day his wife had dragged him to church—long-sleeved in the August heat, trying to hide the yellowing of his skin—and there in the pew he had a revelation. He saw his entire life pass before his eyes, and that’s when he knew that he was being protected by a power greater than himself. He began to weep. And when he got into his car to go home, he looked down and the yellow in his skin had disappeared. A few days later, his doctor told him his tumor was gone.

  The seller signed off by calling me brother. He said my name was a blessing, that Thomas the apostle had doubted the Resurrection, but found his faith when he touched Christ’s wounded body—a miracle! (I have seen the Caravaggio painting of the subject: old doubting Thomas, his forehead creased with awe as Christ grasps his wrist and guides his hand to his bloodless breast, one calloused finger probing the dark gap where the spear went in.) The prophet from War Eagle said that I should not doubt, that mercy was real, and my own miracle would come soon.

  I remember reading the letter at the kitchen island, my dog nosing at my ankles, asking for his dinner. I had switched on Met Opera Radio—as I always did the moment I got home—and while I bore witness to this stranger’s supposed healing and salvation and his promise of my own, I was treated to the end of the first act of Eugene Onegin. (It was the splendid 1992 Bychkov recording; Hvorostovsky is impeccable in the title role.) I folded the letter away as my wife and daughter bustled in through the side door, the sweet jangle of their chatter and the dog’s exuberant yelps drowning out Onegin’s warnings to Tatyana about self-control and inexperience, my dear girls’ voices mingling with the chorus of the maids singing blithely in the garden, cold air exhaling off their bodies as they greeted me, the dog hurling himself at our shins.

  Swimming. It had been swimming. I remember my daughter’s wet hair, her dark curls still stringy and sodden against her neck and collar—the chlorine on her skin when she kissed me.

  * * *

  ■ ■ ■

  Earlier that year my agency had done a television spot for a cancer drug that supposedly added six months or more to the
life spans of truly hopeless cases. The ad opens with a scene of a Mr. Rogers type, struggling to rouse himself from an easy chair, looking fretfully at the stoic face of the clock on the wall. Then it cuts to a woman escorting her elderly mother down a hall, their faces grim. That scene gives way to a handsome man lying in bed, too tired to notice his wife tidying around him.

  These are the sick, the nearly dead, their worlds cool and colorless.

  But then a sunburst comes sparkling into view, a constellation of gold that forms the name of the miracle drug. Honeyed droplets scatter and suffuse the air of each tableau, bringing life to each lost cause.

  Now the Mr. Rogers type is sitting at a newly renovated kitchen counter, playing a game on a digital tablet with his grandson. His own son is chopping vegetables, sneaking a fond gaze at his old man. Now the woman is walking with her mother on a quaint downtown street lined with cherry blossom trees, their faces masks of bliss. Now the handsome man is waltzing with his wife at an outdoor wedding, his hand pressed to the small of her back. They are all alive, defiantly so.

  In the last shot, these people find themselves gathered in a summer field, drawn together by some powerful, benevolent force. They look around, smiling cautiously, unsure if they know each other, but certain they belong there. Before them is a glowing golden obelisk, carved with the miracle drug’s name. They all reach out their hands and step into the light.

  That’s what I did for a living. I spun stories, made things like death seem clean and manageable—attractive, even.

  I don’t really believe in any of it, of course. God, miracles, any of those fantasies. I believe in medicine and advertising, but even those realities aren’t infallible. Sometimes the drug doesn’t work. Sometimes people see through the story you’re trying to sell.

  The most earnest expression of faith I can tolerate is Wagner’s masterpiece Tannhäuser. The titular hero of the opera is a talented court singer in thirteenth-century Germany, and when we first meet him he is ensconced in the sensual grotto of Venus, the pagan goddess of love and lust. Tannhäuser’s appetites have finally been satisfied, and he longs for the wholesome joys of the world he left behind: the soft air of spring and the sound of church bells. He returns to the world of mortals, waking up in a valley outside the city and looking on in gratitude as a chorus of pilgrims passes by on their way to Rome. Tannhäuser’s fellow singers welcome him back into court; the noble-hearted Wolfram persuades him by telling him that the virginal Elisabeth has been pining over him ever since he left. She will be overjoyed to see him again.

  It should be a happy homecoming, but our histrionic hero cannot help himself. Invited to participate in a singing contest about the nature of love, he breaks into a hymn of wanton ecstasy, exposing his sins to all assembled. The court is appalled, and they condemn Tannhäuser to death, but saintly Elisabeth shields him with her body, crying out that the wretch must be allowed to seek salvation through atonement. He must make his own pilgrimage to Rome, and only then will he have the chance to be absolved.

  As the curtain rises on the final act, it is evening in the valley. Autumn. Months have passed, and the good Wolfram watches poor Elisabeth pray, clinging to her last hopes. They hear the pilgrims approach, returning from Rome. As they sing of their journey Elisabeth searches each face, looking for Tannhäuser, but he is not among the faithful. She kneels in defeat; though Wolfram tries to guide her home, she tells him that her path leads toward heaven. She must intercede directly with God to save the man she loves.

  At last Tannhäuser appears, haggard and pale. He tells Wolfram he has failed, that when he reached Rome and sought absolution from the pope, he was forever damned with an awful decree: As this staff in my hand, no more shall bear fresh leaves, from the hot fires of hell, salvation never shall bloom for thee.

  Tannhäuser cries out for Venus, but Wolfram saves him by speaking Elisabeth’s name, breaking the spell once and for all. As dawn comes over the valley, the funeral procession approaches, bearing Elisabeth’s body. Tannhäuser kneels over her, begging with his last breath for her to pray for him. Through the death of the woman who loved him most, he has been redeemed. As our hero dies and the final curtain begins to fall, a young boy runs onstage wielding a flowering staff for all to see.

  End of opera.

  It’s a sublime story of redemption. Even so, I find myself wondering whether it is actually an indictment of belief, a heartbreaking display of its limits. After all, the staff blooms with new flowers only after our hero has died.

  So no, I cannot really say that I am a believer. I suppose I believe in mercy, most of the time, although I doubt I deserve it.

  Even though I’m not a believer, for some reason I regret losing that letter from the man in War Eagle. I’ve often felt that if I could have it back, if I could just see the specifics of its language and revisit its turns of phrase, it would give me some answers about that time in my life. The letter had a crude poetry to it, a certain innocent passion that touched me, somehow. Re-creating it here, I know I’ve missed the heart of it.

  I’ve considered writing to the man and asking him to send me another copy, but for all I know he’s now dead of his supposedly cured cancer. I don’t want to find out.

  And of course, the letter could be nothing like I remember. Like an incantation in a dream that proves meaningless in the morning. I don’t want to find that out either.

  The billy club was for protection. Psychological protection, at least. There was a lot to worry about in those days. There were the things that horrified everyone, of course: assault rifle massacres at office parties, little girls blown to pieces at pop concerts. Everyone could agree that kind of operatic bloodshed was terrible.

  But there were other things that inspired a different kind of fear, things that felt like lead coiled in my gut—the subtler signs of impending catastrophe. Like the paramilitary policemen—America’s own Schutzstaffel—mixed in with the naked cowboys and Mickey Mice and painted ladies in Times Square, close to my office, or the gaunt hunger strikers camped out in the international terminals of airports. Even worse, there were the things that you didn’t see out in the world, things that wouldn’t even make it onto the news—the things you had to find out for yourself on message boards, down rabbit holes of hyperlinks, reading with parched eyes long after midnight. The dread of all that never went away, and it was easy to believe that my life as I knew it was just a paper facade, waiting to be punctured by horrors that could take me from my family—or worse, take my family from me.

  My girls would have told you I wasn’t paranoid or crazy. They might have joked about it, sure—my wife rolling her eyes, my daughter screwing her pretty face into that tasted-a-lemon look she’d paste on when she thought something was funny or ridiculous.

  Daddy, she’d admonish me. Don’t be so silly.

  I could be silly, but I wasn’t crazy. Our lives were good—great, even. We were happy and secure. We had everything we needed.

  There was no way for anyone to know—least of all me—that it would all end the way it did.

  You’ve seen us, I’m sure—in the newspapers, on television, on the web. You’ve probably seen the photograph of us on the beach, even though it’s at least two or three years out of date. It’s sunset, so the flash is on, bleaching out the angel wings of our white linen shirts and highlighting the rosy clouds over the slate ocean behind us. My wife is farthest from the camera, laughing as she begins to peel away from us toward the surf, her slender left arm thrown out in some kind of salute. My daughter is between us, her arms linked tightly with ours, grinning with missing teeth. She was nine or ten, I think. And I’m in the foreground, trying to look dignified, my chin raised in satisfaction and my eyes bright with pride.

  That’s me. That’s us. It feels like another life now.

  Everyone uses the same photo, and they all write increasingly far-fetched variations on the same themes. It seems tha
t after the initial flurry of coverage—after the piece-by-piece assembly of the picture puzzle of events—each new analysis must justify its existence with the promise of fresh insight. They use words like self-righteous, paranoid, disappointed, anomic. They write of revenge, of altruism—of the plight of women and the plight of men. And so on and so on forever and ever, because the puzzle is always incomplete. The pieces refuse to fit; the mirror stays fogged.

  I used to keep up with what was written, but after a while I got tired of all the competing mutations of the story. None of them were ever quite true.

  I have my own struggles with understanding exactly what happened. Sometimes I think I am a victim of circumstance. Sometimes I think I am a monster. Most often, I think I am like Tannhäuser himself—a deeply flawed man who sacrifices everything in an act of desperation, a sinner who can only gain salvation through the death of his most beloved.

  Of course, I know it’s unforgivable to speak of my own pain. How can I even admit that I suffer, when I can still see their faces before me?

  Then again, I am the only one who can tell this story. I am the only one who can speak of the tragedy that befell us.

  * * *

  —

  I know it would make more sense to start at the beginning. That’s how these things always start. The problem is that I’m not sure where the story really begins—how far back I have to go to find the rotted root, deep down in the blackened soil. It may have begun with the billy club, or with the other terrible things that happened that year. Or it may have started even earlier than that. Maybe it began with the happy years with my wife and daughter, or even in my own childhood.

  I’ve never liked beginning new projects. It has always felt like hiking up a hill under a low gray sky, standing around a featureless clearing. I can build anything, and nothing stands in my way, but I have no idea where, or how, to begin. Every choice feels hollow and insufficient, like kicking up clouds of silt that settle back into the ground.